The Weather Journal / Explainers
Rain or Snow: the Line
What reaches the ground, rain, snow, sleet, or freezing rain, is decided by the temperature of the whole column of air the precipitation falls through, not just the reading at your porch. Everything starts as snow aloft in winter storms. A column below freezing top to bottom delivers it as snow. A warm layer partway down, the warm nose, melts it: refreeze the drops in a deep cold layer beneath and you get sleet; keep the cold layer shallow and the drops arrive still liquid, freezing on contact with everything, and that is freezing rain, the dangerous one. The four outcomes can be separated by a hundred miles or a few hours in the same storm.
The column decides, not the porch
In a winter storm, almost everything leaves the cloud as snow. The question the forecast is actually answering is what happens on the way down, through ten or twenty thousand feet of air whose temperature changes with height, and not always in one direction. Your thermometer samples the last six feet of that trip. The precipitation type was mostly settled before the flake or drop got anywhere near it, which is why the rain-or-snow call is a forecast about air you cannot see, made with balloon soundings and model profiles of the column overhead.
The warm nose
The mischief-maker is a layer of above-freezing air sandwiched into an otherwise cold column, usually between a few thousand and ten thousand feet up. Forecasters call it the warm nose, because on a temperature-versus-height chart it bulges out warm and then tucks back cold below. It is most often warm air riding up the long shallow ramp of a warm front, gliding over cold surface air that is too dense and too stubborn to leave. North of a winter , sliding up a long shallow ramp over the cooler air ahead. Its clouds arrive high and thin as much as a day early, then lower and thicken into steady, patient rain.">warm is exactly where the atmosphere builds this sandwich, which is why the nastiest ice events live on the cold side of a storm track, not the cold-est side.
Whether the snow survives the nose, and what happens to whatever melts, comes down to two numbers: how warm and deep the nose is, and how cold and deep the layer under it is. Four combinations, four kinds of precipitation.
The four endings
- Snow. The column stays at or below freezing the whole way down, or close enough that flakes survive. Silent on arrival, as its own lesson explains, and honest about accumulating.
- Sleet. The flakes melt partly or fully in the warm nose, then fall through a cold layer thousands of feet deep, long enough to refreeze into ice pellets. Sleet bounces off the car hood and taps on the windows. Miserable, noisy, and structurally harmless compared with what is next.
- ingredient.">Freezing rain. The flakes melt completely, and the cold layer under the nose is too shallow to refreeze them. The drops arrive as liquid a few degrees below freezing, supercooled, and on contact with every surface at or under 32: roads, lines, branches, windshields. It looks exactly like rain while it falls. That is the trap.
- Rain. The lower column is simply warm. The storm is a storm, but it is water, and water drains.
Freezing rain is the dangerous one
Say it plainly, because this is the sentence the lesson exists for: of the four, freezing rain is the one that hurts people. Glaze ice is heavy, and it accumulates on exactly the infrastructure that holds weight worst: a coating on spans of power line and tree limbs adds up to tons across a neighborhood, and the lines and limbs come down together. On pavement it is nearly invisible, black ice that looks wet rather than frozen, and it turns roads and front steps into surfaces no tread grips. Ice Storm Warnings are typically issued when accretion is expected to reach around a quarter of an inch, with the threshold set by your local office; what a warning versus a watch versus an advisory obliges you to do is that lesson's whole subject. During the event itself, the observation protocol is one word long: indoors. Every fact in this lesson is checkable through a window, and in an ice storm the window is where the science stops.
The surface temperature is still lying to you
Two porch-thermometer traps remain even after you respect the column. First, snow does not require a freezing thermometer: flakes falling from a cold column survive a while in surface air in the mid 30s, which is why fat flakes can fall at 35 with nothing sticking. Second, the column can cool itself mid-storm. When precipitation falls into dry air, evaporation collects its heat tax and drags the air toward its wet-bulb temperature, so a storm that begins as chilly rain can turn itself to snow in an hour without any arriving; the precipitation did the cooling. Forecasters watch wet-bulb profiles for exactly this reason. And the ground votes last: pavement holding warmth from yesterday melts the first inch of anything, while a subfreezing bridge deck, cooled from both sides, ices first, which is why the sign says so.
None of this involves a lake, by the way; the machine that buries one shoreline town under feet of snow while the sun shines inland is its own lesson. This one is about layered storms, and the line they draw.
Watch the line move, from inside
The next time precipitation is due with the temperature within a few degrees of freezing, run the changeover watch, entirely from indoors. Each hour, predict first: given the current temperature, what type falls next hour? Then verify without opening the door, because the evidence carries: snow is silent and softens the streetlight cone, rain patters, sleet ticks against the glass like thrown sand. Log the type, the temperature, and the time. If you catch a changeover, note how far the thermometer was from 32 when it happened; it is rarely where a porch-only theory would put it. You will have observed the warm nose doing its work miles overhead, from an armchair, which is the correct furniture for an ice storm.
Words in this lesson
Every marked word above is here in full, because a definition that only appears on hover is no use to somebody reading on a phone, printing the page, or listening to it.
- Air mass
- A huge body of air, hundreds of miles across, that has sat in one place long enough to take on that place's temperature and moisture. Most day to day weather is the story of air masses shoving each other around.
- Cold front
- The leading edge of an advancing cold air mass. Its dense air wedges under the warm air ahead and shoves it up fast, so its weather is short and sharp, followed by clearing skies and drier air.
- Freeze
- Air at or below 32 F.
- Freezing rain
- Supercooled rain that ices everything it touches. The ice storm ingredient.
- Front
- The boundary where two air masses of different temperature and moisture meet. Air gets lifted along a front, which is why most of a map's clouds and rain queue up on one.
- Ice storm
- Freezing rain event. Warnings near 1/4 inch of glaze (varies by region); 1/2 inch snaps trees.
- Warm front
- The leading edge of an advancing warm air mass, sliding up a long shallow ramp over the cooler air ahead. Its clouds arrive high and thin as much as a day early, then lower and thicken into steady, patient rain.
Definitions in this explainer follow the National Weather Service. The rock checked twice. The rock always checks twice.